ETHICAL ISSUES IN INVOLUNTARY ADMISSION AND TREATMENT BY DR EDEBOR EHIREMEN DAVIDSON

  • Home
  • -
  • Clinical Meetings
  • -
  • ETHICAL ISSUES IN INVOLUNTARY ADMISSION AND TREATMENT BY DR EDEBOR EHIREMEN DAVIDSON
 ETHICAL ISSUES IN INVOLUNTARY ADMISSION AND TREATMENT BY DR EDEBOR EHIREMEN DAVIDSON

OUTLINE

Preamble: The Central Ethical Question

Introduction and Central Ethical Dilemma

Ethical and Philosophical Foundations

Arguments for and against Involuntary Treatment

Ethical Issues

Nigerian Legal and Human-Rights Framework

Case Report

Clinical Application and Safeguards

Conclusion

INTRODUCTION

Ethical principles in conflict:

Autonomy: Respect the person’s informed choices, values, bodily integrity and participation.

Beneficence: Promote health, welfare and relief of suffering; intervene where likely to help.

Non-maleficence: Avoid harm from illness and from coercion: trauma, adverse effects, injury and loss of trust.

Justice: Avoid harm from illness and from coercion: trauma, adverse effects, injury and loss of trust.

Ethical Foundations: Two approaches to ethical reasoning.

Duty-based reasoning asks what the psychiatrist is obliged to do: respect rights, obtain consent, preserve confidentiality, maintain dignity and follow lawful procedure.

Utilitarian reasoning considers the foreseeable balance of benefits and harms of the available options for the patient and others.

The approaches overlap, but can point in different directions: a potentially beneficial intervention may still violate duties if imposed without adequate justification.

Complex decisions benefit from multidisciplinary discussion, explicit examination of competing values and legal or ethics advice where needed.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *